Quantity and specification
Compare the same required specification and normalized quantity; keep source versions.
SOURCINGRECORD / Method worksheet
Start with a prior comparable purchase. Document the adjustments and incremental costs before counting any accepted outcome as value.
Illustrative values only
$1,140 · 200 pairs · 15 days
$1,020 · 200 pairs · 30 days
$30 · comparability held
A clearer record.
A considered decision.
THE CHECKLIST
The baseline is held until the owner can approve a defensible comparison.
Compare the same required specification and normalized quantity; keep source versions.
Document landed cost, freight, relevant taxes, currency basis and delivery conditions.
Account for review hours, approved hourly cost, pilot fee allocation and other category-specific costs.
THE FAILED RECOMMENDATION
The prior purchase is $1,140 at 15 days. Juniper is $1,020 at 30 days. A lower number cannot silently resolve that delivery difference.
$1,140 / $1,020 · illustrative
15 vs 30 days · held
$30 · pilot fee must also count
ILLUSTRATIVE / SYNTHETIC INPUTS
If comparability were explicitly approved with a zero delivery adjustment, the synthetic arithmetic would be:
This single-order scenario does not establish positive pilot value. Purchase frequency, allocation and reviewed net value need buyer evidence. Unaccepted offers remain excluded from savings.
A BOUNDED NEXT STEP
Start with a permissioned closed RFQ. Agree a named owner, approved envelope and supplier-consented scope before any live pilot.