RESEARCH-STAGE CONCEPTInspect the synthetic demo

SOURCINGRECORD / Method worksheet

Make the baseline comparable before counting value.

Start with a prior comparable purchase. Document the adjustments and incremental costs before counting any accepted outcome as value.

Illustrative values only

Method worksheetThree assumption cards settle; the 15-versus-30-day hold remains visible. Illustrative values onlyPrior comparable$1,140200 pairs; 15 daysSelected quote$1,020200 pairs; 30 daysReview effort$300.5h × $60/hComparability held: 15 vs 30 daysNo realized savings. Pilot fees excluded from this illustration.Method worksheetIllustrative values onlySR / 17
01
Prior purchase

$1,140 · 200 pairs · 15 days

02
Selected quote

$1,020 · 200 pairs · 30 days

03
Review effort

$30 · comparability held

Illustrative values only

A clearer record.
A considered decision.

SOURCE · COMPARISON · REVIEW

THE CHECKLIST

Match the basis first.

The baseline is held until the owner can approve a defensible comparison.

01

Quantity and specification

Compare the same required specification and normalized quantity; keep source versions.

02

Freight, currency and terms

Document landed cost, freight, relevant taxes, currency basis and delivery conditions.

03

Incremental costs

Account for review hours, approved hourly cost, pilot fee allocation and other category-specific costs.

THE FAILED RECOMMENDATION

The RF-202 calculation
is deliberately held.

The prior purchase is $1,140 at 15 days. Juniper is $1,020 at 30 days. A lower number cannot silently resolve that delivery difference.

Baseline bridgeTwo directly labeled cost bars enter once; review cost and comparability hold stay visible. Illustrative; not realized savingsIllustrative cost comparison · USDPrior basis$1,140Quote total$1,0200400800120015 vs 30 days · comparability held · not realized savingsReview cost $30 and pilot fee must be included in a reviewed net-value test.Baseline bridgeIllustrative; not realized savingsSR / 07
01
Prior / quote

$1,140 / $1,020 · illustrative

02
Comparability

15 vs 30 days · held

03
Review effort

$30 · pilot fee must also count

Illustrative cost chart; not realized savings.

ILLUSTRATIVE / SYNTHETIC INPUTS

What the arithmetic actually says.

If comparability were explicitly approved with a zero delivery adjustment, the synthetic arithmetic would be:

Prior basis − quote total$1,140 − $1,020 = $120
Review cost0.5h × $60/h = $30
Scenario before fees$120 − $30 = $90
Whole $2,500 pilot fee on one order$90 − $2,500 = −$2,410

This single-order scenario does not establish positive pilot value. Purchase frequency, allocation and reviewed net value need buyer evidence. Unaccepted offers remain excluded from savings.

A BOUNDED NEXT STEP

Put one category under review.

Start with a permissioned closed RFQ. Agree a named owner, approved envelope and supplier-consented scope before any live pilot.

Discuss a category pilotInquiry form preview · nothing submitted